The IMO Net-Zero Framework, Between Stalemate and Actionable Policies

After a tumultuous early November 2026 at the International Maritime Organization (IMO), the USA formally opposed the passing of the Net-Zero Framework (NZF). The NFZ is designed to cap greenhouse gas emissions from ships through a global renewable fuel standard and carbon-pricing mechanisms. While opposing, the US delegation labelled the framework as a hidden carbon tax that would impose an additional $265 billion in annual industry costs. Though having been provisionally approved in April 2025, the framework had already been adjourned during the second extraordinary session of the Marine Environment Protection Committee (MEPC ES.2) held on 14–17 October 2025. Due to the US opposition, the vote for the Net-Zero Framework will now take place during MEPC 85 from 30 November to 3 December 2026.

This vote is decisive, as it would impose a CO2 cap on fleets around the world and push them into becoming greener. However, the Net-Zero Framework is being criticised as not being fairly thought through, with a carbon cap that is not equitably distributed. Member states from Small Island Developing States (SIDS) and Least Developed Countries (LDCs) would face real difficulties upgrading their existing infrastructure and fleets and therefore face penalties, while wealthier countries might argue over the management of the efficiency of the carbon cap fund.

Regional mechanism: EU Emission Trading System (ETS)

While a universal framework is still being debated, Europe has imposed its own rules in phases through the EU Emissions Trading System (ETS), extended to shipping in January 2024, and FuelEU Maritime since 1 January 2025. These instruments monitor the AIS data of both foreign and national fleets and impose a greenhouse gas cap. Fleet companies must surrender EU allowances (EUAs), and ships must currently meet a 2% reduction in fuel greenhouse gas intensity compared to the 2020 baseline. The target is to cut greenhouse gas intensity from ships by 6% by 2030 and by 80% by 2050. Starting 1 January 2030, further offshore power rules will also require container and passenger ships to use onshore power supplies at major EU ports.

As a note, Net Zero Framework (NZF) of IMO is setting goals for the total of CO2 emissions from international shipping and is aiming to achieve 0% of CO2 emissions by 2050 compared to 2008. The Fuel EU Maritime from the EU is aiming to regulate the lifecycle emissions per unit of energy used on board. The EU has on top emitted a ETS strategy requiring companies emitting over a certain quota of CO2 to surrender allowances.  Together with the Fuel EU Maritime and the EU ETS, the NZF is aiming to regulate and transform the CO2 emissions of the international shipping sector. 

According to the European Commission, early data retrieved from vessels venturing into EU waters shows these instruments are working. Compared to 2025, emissions in 2026 dropped by 3%, and administrative compliance from shipping companies reached 99%. Narrowing the price gap between alternative and conventional fuels has also led to the adoption of more sustainable fuels and energy-saving devices. Meanwhile, the funds raised by the EU ETS, which reached €38.8 billion across sectors in 2024, were used primarily to tackle climate change and support the clean transition for the infrastructure of EU member countries. However, because these instruments are still evolving and being tested, the shipping industry has yet to face the full financial and technological stress coming in 2030. The EU example shows how to start implementing a net-zero framework, but it does not yet provide a clear baseline on how to do it properly, as EU instruments have still not reached the point where the entire industry must adapt.

Homework at Policy Intersections

Contrary to the EU, where rules apply only in European waters, the IMO’s Net-Zero Framework will affect the global maritime industry and countries worldwide. The decision lying on the shoulders of the 176 member states this December is whether the framework, as it stands, serves their interests and helps the IMO in its mission to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 100% by 2050. That means agreeing on the terms for zero or near-zero (ZNZ) emission technologies, fuels, and energy sources. This is deeply concerning for some member states, as the world relies on shipping, with over 80% of goods moving from one continent to another. Shifting levies from conventional fuel to sustainable alternatives will also force companies to overhaul not just production and infrastructure, but the entire sourcing and burning of fuel, commonly referred to as well-to-wake. The money collected from penalties into the NZF Fund which is projected to be around $15 billion, would help reward shipowners having adopted the ZNZ, fund just transition projects in developing nations, for SIDS to receive targeted support and help training initiatives to raise awareness around green technologies. At the same time, lower-income countries and wealthier nations must work together on how to fairly distribute the funds collected by the IMO to support and reward countries and companies abiding by the new rules. They need to make sure that the money does not reward already rich companies or a tax evasive project.  

This raises a central question: will the IMO remain impartial when redistributing these funds to the countries that have earned them, and will the levy actually go toward investing in port facilities and refurbishing fleets that need new engines to burn alternative fuels? 

Apart from pioneering big shipowners, maritime workforce projects and clean fuel developers, recipients of the fund are mostly countries who are SIDS and LDCs. These states would vest in the refurbishments of infrastructure and fleets through building companies owned by the private sector. Most companies bidding to undertake the projects are generally companies who are the cheapest.. The main question with this operation is to review which companies local, in need of support and who through their undertaking are influencing the local economy. Endorsing private sector companies and keeping out the monopoly will be a challenge as certain companies are leading the market. To avoid this imbalance, the international community could implement an impartial and incorruptible oversight body to avoid creating a rift between big and small companies and avoid a monopoly. Its creation will then depend entirely on the member states and could be attached to the IMO. However, the implementation and the legal ramifications will take years to shape the perfect solution and probably will overstep the target set by the IMO for ships to reach carbon neutrality by 2050. 

Another question lies within the sustainable fuels themselves. Although it is still in the test phase in ports and engineering trials due to being highly toxic, ammonia was cleared under IMO Interim Guidelines and the IGC Code in December 2024, with updated seafarer training guidelines enabling its safe handling. Under these rules, shipping companies are allowed to build and operate ammonia-powered ships without the old case-by-case government exemptions. Yet some so-called sustainable fuels would not truly contribute to achieving Net-Zero Framework and EU ETS goals at all. This stems from their production phase, where forests and rainforests may have been cleared through logging and fires. Because forests recover slowly, young trees cannot cover the amassed carbon debt.

For the IMO’s Net-Zero Framework to succeed in the real world, ambition must be matched with accountability, safety, and fairness. Stricter well-to-wake fuel certification rules and an extended testing phase are essential not only to prevent false labelling and third-party-funded deforestation, but also to protect seafarers handling toxic fuels and to stop non-CO2 setbacks like methane and nitrous oxide leaks. At the same time, greening global shipping requires balanced investment that supports private companies while upgrading older infrastructure across SIDS, LDCs, and both developed and developing nations alike. Doing so would prevent a two-tier market where clean vessels serve wealthy routes while older, dirtier ships are pushed onto developing economies. As the framework undergoes review, policymakers must account for the sharp financial disparities among member states, striking a careful balance between pricing greenhouse gas emissions and avoiding harsh penalties on countries and smaller operators that still lack the tools to track every ton.


Ada Schmitdkunz, Senior Programme Delivery Manager

Next
Next

Why Stakeholder Governance Matters for Business Success